Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process: Indian Journal of Commerce, Business & Management (IJCBM)

Overview :
The Indian Journal of Commerce, Business & Management (IJCBM) employs a rigorous double-blind peer review process to ensure the quality, validity, and originality of published research. This process involves independent reviewers evaluating manuscripts based on their academic merit, relevance, and contribution to the field.

Steps in the Peer Review Process

1. Submission:
   • Authors submit their manuscripts through the journal’s online submission system.
   • Manuscripts are screened for compliance with submission guidelines and relevance to the journal’s scope.
2. Initial Review:
   • The editorial team conducts an initial review to assess the manuscript’s suitability for peer review.
   • Manuscripts that do not meet the journal’s standards or scope may be rejected without peer review.
3. Peer Review:
   • Manuscripts are assigned to at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the relevant field.
   • Reviewers evaluate the manuscript based on criteria such as:
     • Originality and significance of the research.
     • Soundness of methodology and data analysis.
     • Clarity and coherence of writing.
     • Relevance and contribution to the field.
4. Reviewer Feedback:
   • Reviewers provide detailed feedback and recommendations to the editor, which may include:
     • Accept as is.
     • Minor revisions.
     • Major revisions.
     • Reject.
5. Editorial Decision:
   • The editor considers the reviewers’ feedback and makes a decision regarding the manuscript.
   • Authors are notified of the decision and provided with reviewer comments.
6. Revisions and Resubmission:
   • If revisions are required, authors are given the opportunity to address reviewer comments and resubmit their manuscript.
   • Revised manuscripts may undergo additional peer review.
7. Final Decision:
   • Once the manuscript meets the journal’s standards, the editor makes a final decision to accept the manuscript for publication.

Peer Review Criteria

1. Originality:
   • Does the manuscript present new findings or approaches?
2. Significance:
   • Does the research contribute to the field or address important issues?
3. Methodology:
   • Are the research methods appropriate and well-described?
4. Data Analysis:
   • Are the data analysis and interpretation sound?
5. Clarity and Coherence:
   • Is the writing clear, concise, and well-organized?
6. Relevance:
   • Is the research relevant to the journal’s scope and audience?

Benefits of Peer Review

1. Quality Assurance:
   • Ensures that published research meets high academic standards.
2. Constructive Feedback:
   • Provides authors with valuable feedback to improve their work.
3. Credibility:
   • Enhances the credibility of the journal and its published research.
4. Advancement of Knowledge:
   • Facilitates the dissemination of high-quality research that contributes to the advancement of knowledge.

Timeline
The peer review process typically takes several weeks to a few months, depending on the availability of reviewers and the complexity of the manuscript.

By adhering to a rigorous Double blind peer review process, theIndian Journal of Commerce, Business & Management (IJCBM) ensures the publication of high-quality research that meets the standards of the academic community.